It's no accident that the MSM is spinning this in the wake of a strong conservative electoral success !Proportional Representation... It boils down to this ....
When you can't succeed by the rules everyone lives with then bitch and moan about the rules.
Proportional representation advocates claim that it's more fair. Except they won't acknowledge that it's just a way of stacking the deck based on creating further social divisions and opening the door to the kind of un-democratic political coalitions that prevail everywhere it is used.
Update on this point:Arguments that claim because voter turn out is low we have less democracy are fallacious.Those who choose not to participate are voluntarily forgoing their rights. This is not a problem that is the result of our electoral system, rather it is a symptom of social malaise that I would squarely put at the feet of the same sort of people who would promote PR as the solution. I say that PR would do nothing to correct this and that no one is able to demonstrate otherwise.
Point of fact is that voter turn out in European nations who have various forms of PR is as bad or worse than our own. I might as well argue that true proportional representation would account for low voter turnout by taking a proportional number of representative positions out of parliament. In other words how about if Toronto turned out only 36% of eligible voters? Could we then argue that 64% of the MP seats from the area be eliminated? would that be more democratic or less?Is my suggestion going to make a better democracy or is it simply absurd?No more or less absurd than the arguments offered in favour of PR!Voter participation is simply a canard in the discussion. Irrelevant to the matter of whether or not PR is a better system than our own.------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Previous :They point to the fact that in Canada and in the USA we are in the minority of nations who do not adopt this or similar forms of representation. They do not care to acknowledge that in fact our government works much better because we do not follow the herd.
They claim that it is more democratic .... not acknowledging that the concept is at its root a socialistic idea that regards the so called rights of groups who cannot succeed without some systemic form of interference on their behalf to be of greater importance than having the actual level playing field that respects the one
citizen = one vote rule in favour of a form of affirmative action that rewards failures and incompetence rather than providing some level of filtration to eliminate the waste from the system.
They who promote proportional representation are in fact the same sort that demand their children be allowed to play on sports teams that they do not qualify for. They are same people who have promoted the steady lowering of standards in our education systems. They are the same people who constantly feel free to end any meaningful debate with some invocation of political correctness. They are the same people whose fall back position is always seeking the interference of the Nurse Nanny state.
.... they are whiners.
Canada's electoral system works and it is the BEST system to elect a parliament.
We do not need to follow the herd of dysfunctional nations down the toilet bowl of political correctness or socialistic statism by adopting the electoral processes that only encourage such devolution.
The fact is We Are Better because of our institutions and the only conclusions that can be drawn from the moaning of those who wish to change this is that they are either completely ignorant of and blind to the consequences of adopting their ideas or that they are willfully advocating for a weaker and more socialistic nation.
Either way ignoramuses or outright enemies of our society the proponents of proportional representation should be viewed with suspicion and disdain.
It's no accident that the MSM is spinning this in the wake of a strong conservative electoral success !
OMMAGLabels: Canada, Consequenses, Know Your Enemy, Opinions, Politics