Software test estimation is the process of predicting the time, effort, and resources required for testing activities. It considers project size, complexity, risks, and team capability to create a realistic testing plan.
- Test planning and execution are controlled.
- Test design and analysis are performed during the testing process.
- Test execution and evaluation are carried out during the testing phase.
- Test closure and reporting are done after testing is completed.
Key Elements to Estimate in Software Testing
When estimating software testing, there are several key factors to consider:
- Time: Estimate how long testing will take to meet deadlines and SLAs. Proper planning ensures timely delivery without delays.
- Resources: Include team, tools, and equipment required for testing. Efficient use prevents wastage and improves productivity.
- Cost: Define the budget for the testing phase and manage expenses. Accurate estimation avoids overspending and keeps the project on track.
- Skillset: Consider team experience and expertise while assigning tasks. Skilled members complete work faster and more accurately.
- Risks: Identify possible challenges like technical issues or delays early. Planning for risks helps reduce their impact on timeline and cost.
Steps to Perform Test Estimation
Test estimation is typically performed in four simple steps:
Step 1: Divide the Project into Small Tasks
Use the Work Breakdown Structure (WBS) to break a large project into smaller, manageable tasks in a top-down manner. This helps simplify complex testing work and improves estimation accuracy.
- Break project into modules, sub-modules, and functionalities
- Suitable for large and complex projects
- Follows a top-down approach: goal → deliverables → activities → tasks
- Makes tasks independent and easier to estimate and manage
Step 2. Allocate each task to suitable team members
After breaking the project into smaller tasks, assign each task to suitable team members based on their skills, experience, and expertise. This ensures efficient execution and better quality output.
- Assign tasks based on skillset and experience
- Ensure balanced workload among team members
- Improves efficiency and accountability in execution
Step 3. Estimate the effort required to complete each task
Estimate the time and effort required for each task using techniques like Three-Point Estimation or Function Point Analysis. This helps improve accuracy by considering different scenarios and task complexity.
1. Three-Point Estimation (PERT): This technique uses three scenarios:
- Optimistic (O): Best case (everything goes smoothly)
- Most Likely (M): Normal case
- Worst (W): Worst case (issues occur)
Formula: E = (O + 4M + W) / 6
Example (Login Feature Testing):
This example demonstrates how testing effort for a login feature is estimated using different scenarios. It helps in getting a realistic estimate by considering best, normal, and worst cases.
Given: O = 2 hrs, M = 4 hrs, W = 6 hrs
Calculation:
- E = (O + 4M + W) / 6
- E = (2 + 16 + 6) / 6 = 4 hrs
Estimated Effort = 4 ± 1 hours
2. Function Point Analysis (FP): Estimates effort based on functionality and complexity:
- Assign points based on complexity (Easy, Medium, Hard)
- Calculate total effort using assigned weights
Example (Function Point Analysis):
This example shows how testing effort is estimated based on the complexity of different modules. Each feature is assigned points according to its difficulty level.
Given:
- Login (Easy) = 2 points
- Dashboard (Medium) = 3 points
- Payment (Hard) = 5 points
Calculation: Total FP = 2 + 3 + 5 = 10
If 1 FP = $10 -> Total Cost = $100
Step 4. Validate the estimation
Once effort estimates are prepared, they are reviewed and validated by stakeholders to ensure accuracy and feasibility. This step helps align the estimation with project goals and available resources.
- Review estimates with managers and stakeholders
- Check for accuracy, risks, and missing factors
- Final approval ensures realistic and achievable planning
Software Test Estimation Techniques
Estimating time, effort, and resources for testing ensures efficient execution and alignment with project goals. Below are commonly used techniques:
1. Work Breakdown Structure (WBS)
WBS divides large testing tasks into smaller, manageable components. It simplifies planning and execution of complex projects.
- Breaks tasks into smaller sub-tasks
- Improves tracking and resource allocation
- Makes complex work easier to manage
2. Functional Point Analysis (FP)
FP estimates effort based on functionality and complexity of the system. Each module is assigned points based on difficulty.
- Categorizes features (Easy, Medium, Hard)
- Effort = Functional Points × cost per FP
- Helps measure project size clearly
3. Wideband Delphi Technique
This technique uses expert opinions to estimate effort through discussion and consensus. It ensures more reliable estimation.
- Involves experienced team members
- Encourages multiple viewpoints
- Assumptions are documented clearly
4. Three-Point Estimation (PERT)
This method estimates effort using three scenarios: best, most likely, and worst case. It provides a balanced and realistic estimate.
- Uses O (Optimistic), M (Most Likely), W (Worst)
- Formula: (O + 4M + W) / 6
- Reduces uncertainty in estimation
5. Use-Case Based Estimation
Effort is estimated based on user interactions with the system. Each use case represents a real-world scenario.
- Focuses on user behavior
- Helps identify issues early
- Useful in initial stages
6. Percentage Distribution
Effort is divided among different testing phases based on importance. It helps in quick and simple estimation.
- Assigns % to testing types
- Easy to apply and understand
- No tools required
7. Ad-Hoc Estimation
An informal approach where estimation is based on experience and intuition. Often used for quick testing scenarios.
- It includes Buddy, Pair, and Monkey testing.
- Fast and flexible approach
- Helps find unexpected defects
Test Estimation Best Practices
Test estimation becomes more accurate and reliable when teams follow structured practices like proper planning, learning from past projects, and considering real-world uncertainties.
- Resource Planning: Ensure proper allocation of people, tools, and timelines
- Use Past Experience: Refer to previous projects to improve estimation accuracy
- Add Buffer Time: Account for risks like delays, bugs, or team changes
- Stick to Estimates: Avoid frequent changes unless major requirements change
- Consider Bug Cycle: Include time for defect fixing and retesting
- Define Project Scope: Clearly understand size and complexity of the project
- Plan for Load & Parallel Testing: Include performance and version comparison efforts in estimates