TraschcanOfIdeology [they/them, comrade/them]

  • 17 Posts
  • 2.78K Comments
Joined 5 years ago
Aquileo | cake
Cake day: August 3rd, 2021

Aquileo | help-circle










  • old Russian crank wrote about Marxist thermodynamics

    I remember this guy, he was trying to reach the same conclusions of thermodynamics through dialectics. Kind of weird crank stuff, didn’t add anything new to either Marxism or thermodynamics AFAIK.

    The Saito text that mentions thermodynamics and Marx’s thoughts on classical thermodynamics and the political economy of energy and planetary metabolism was “Karl Marx’s ecosocialism”, which deals with late Marx’s reflections and the unpublished 3rd volume of Capital.

    Regarding Posadas writing weird stuff about the SU it’s likely that some kind of distorted version of scientific news from the SU got repeated so much that he actually read “Soviets discover rays faster than light”, when it was some theoretical or particle physics report that didn’t do anything like that. The article was written during the peak of soviet secrecy and paranoia so unfounded rumors must’ve been all over the place



  • in the Soviet Union, they have discovered a ray infinitely faster than light

    Posadas just straight up making shit up lmao.

    He does have a point that from a thermodynamic point of view: the kinds of compounds that give place to life are more energy efficient than inorganic ones, given the activation energy necessary and the right conditions are provided. Life is more stable than non-life, if life happens to exist in the first place.

    Marxism and classic thermodynamics do have a lot of concepts in common, with Marx being very interested in advances in Thermodynamics in the 1800s and adapting some of its ideas to Marxist understanding (I learned this from reading Kohei Saito)

    In an infinitely large and complex universe, life existing in multiple places is all but a certainty. Our universe isn’t infinite (as far as we know), but it might as well be. That being said, it makes no epistemological sense to claim “life exists outside of earth”, as it is an unfalsifiable statement unless we have mapped the whole universe out