Showing posts with label ukraine. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ukraine. Show all posts

Thursday, 26 January 2023

I Don't Quite Get It

Going through old photographs, I found this from the Times of April 2020. It seems there was a time, not long ago at all, when even professional journalists could not tell the difference between Hungary and Ukraine.



This only intensified my confusion about what we are doing in Ukraine. 

While it is clear Putin is a thug and a monster and Ukraine has been attacked without having done anything that could be interpreted as aggressive provocation, what I don't understand is why this conflict is being treated so differently to the conflicts in other countries where in recent decades equally unfair attacks have been made - and in some cases the aggressor has been Putin, just like now. 

Somehow, the whole of the West has been whipped up into wild outrage by this particular war, as opposed to all the many cruel unfair wars in the world that we usually turn a blind eye to - in fact, simultaneous with expressing our horror at what is happening in Ukraine, we are turning the blindest of blind eyes to poor old Armenia, under regular and unjustified attack from Azerbaijan. Azerbaijan, in fact, at least, according to Ursula von der Leyen, is a reliable and trustworthy partner, not like brutal Russia at all (except it is). 

So why here, why now, do we suddenly find our (selective) moral compass? And most especially, why here? I mean, when Boris Johnson wrote in his usual bombastic way, "What conceivable grounds can there be for delay" in providing more assistance and weaponry for the Ukrainians to fight back against Russia, was I the only one to think, "Er, mate, the fact that you are taking on a madman with a vast nuclear arsenal who, if driven too hard, might decide to use those weapons, because he is cruel, blood thirsty and completely mad and if we leave him nothing to lose who knows what will happen."

Am I a dreadful appeaser? Or is there something to be said for noting that Hitler did not have nuclear weapons and Putin does, and therefore the situation between Russia and Ukraine might deserve a slightly more delicate strategy than simply going in hard, hard, hard?

The Ukrainians are in the right, no doubt about it, but so many others are - and have been - in similar skirmishes. Why have we all suddenly found our morality for this war but no others? And, having found our compass, are we sure the best solution to what is a horrific problem is to goad the bear?

I sound pusillanimous. I am. But I am also suspicious, simply because our response to what is happening in Ukraine strikes me as very much the exception to the rule, and I would like to know why that is.

And somehow I don't feel tremendously encouraged by the news that there has just been a purge of very senior people in the Ukrainian government who were corrupt - not because the purge isn't good news but because the news only came yesterday, suggesting to me that we have all been going round thinking this is a fight between good and bad, when actually it's a fight between not that great and terrible, in terms of the leaders. 

Would the purge have happened, I wonder, if the Ukrainian leadership hadn't been forced into it by us, its new allies? Who are we dealing with really - not the civilians but those who run things in the Ukrainian government? If Ukraine wins and the immediate aftermath is not that we are all drenched in radioactive fallout, will the corrupt individuals purged yesterday come sliding back and resume their business? Are we being encouraged into a huge and endless war because of some other agenda, or is it just that Ukrainian civilians are more attractive to us than those in the Caucasus or Armenia? Is Putin really a threat to the entire free world or is he just an elderly thuggish Russian with stupid dreams that he cannot actually sustain or even fulfil? 

Tuesday, 15 February 2022

The Age of Hypocrisy

As I am expert in nothing, anything I say is probably rubbish. In that context, I predict that there will be no invasion of Ukraine by Russia any time soon. (Note 1) 

I don't know what, if anything, Putin is up to - not much, quite probably. What I suspect is that actually it is the Biden administration that is beating up the Ukraine question, hoping that, having done so and got enough people panicking, if there is no invasion, they can claim they have achieved something, (quite a few governments have discovered the usefulness of frightening voters over the last two years).

Meanwhile, the Johnson administration is also beating up the idea that there will soon be a Russian invasion - for them this is simply a "look-over-there" strategy designed to make the public think that Johnson is a statesman and not a party going, spineless arse (not a strategy with any chance of success, I predict, as a non-expert).

Whatever Putin's intention, what this episode has exposed exceptionally clearly to me is that the part of the world where one might once have claimed there was something called Western civilisation is now not civilised at all. It has become the zone of Western hypocrisy, ruled over by a bunch of posturing, greedy, self-serving mugs - or are they thugs? I suppose they can be both. 

Once upon a time, the West did have principles and values (oh shut up about slavery, we didn't invent it and we abolished it as soon as we thought about it carefully). At the beginning of the Second World War it recognised - if reluctantly - that Adolf Hitler was exceptionally wicked and it was necessary to stop his advance. During the Cold War, it recognised that the Soviet Union was an appalling machine for grinding down innocent souls. Looking at Cultural Revolution China, it recognised that a dangerous murderer was in charge - and, ineffectively but not necessarily wrongly, tried to stop the spread of that dangerous murderer's system of government throughout South-East Asia.

Now things are different. We pretend to disapprove of Russia and China, while making our economies daily more dependent on them, intertwining ourselves with them so thoroughly that we have become complicit in every single wicked thing they do. 

Despite knowing that Mr Putin's regime is rotten to the core, Europe has allowed itself to become utterly dependent on the gas that regime produces. Britain meanwhile has a financial sector that is so riddled with dirty Russian money that no one in power dares do anything serious in retaliation to any monstrous action that Putin cares to dream up (not even in response to a nuclear attack on British soil, which is what the murder of Alexander Litvinenko was). 

Similarly, despite disapproving of China - its coal-fired stations, its treatment of its minority peoples - the West welcomed it into our trading sphere, ostensibly on the naive assumption that by doing so Chinese rulers would suddenly see the error of their ways and establish genuine democracy where the Chinese people would be the true rulers rather than merely the thoroughly brainwashed ruled. 

But we didn't insist on any changes in China, strangely. Perhaps we didn't really care what happened to the Chinese people, provided they kept doing our dirty work - and doing it wonderfully inexpensively so that we could fill our houses up with mass-produced stuff. We turned the blindest of blind eyes to China's vile approach to human rights and its frightful treatment of the environment, in exchange for having our shops filled with bright shiny cheap things, which many of us too late discovered that we could no longer buy, since our jobs had been taken by slaves in China. 

But who cares really? Who cares if China is opening multiple coalfired power stations, provided they can make our solar panels, without our ever having to become aware of the pollution that is a consequence of every panel made. And isn't it wonderful to be able to go into a Tesco superstore and buy a cheap television to while away the hours we are no longer working, even if it is made by slave labour. 

The great thing is the profits of big Western companies are up, black lives matter, and we don't have any slaves. And we believe in human rights and our police don't beat us up for expressing opinions that differ from the government line.

But hang on. Whoops. What happened to our moral high ground? Look at the emergency measures just introduced in Canada, look at the footage from across the world in the last year or so, showing police in France and Germany and other so-called democratic nations beating up those who dare to come out on the street to question government measures that have never been taken to a democratic election to be approved. 

Mr Putin this week, whether he intended to or not, has shown that the West isn't going to do anything to curtail his excesses, because it is caught in his web, it is party to everything that he does. In exactly the same way - possibly even more troublingly, - the West is party to all China's excesses as well, because we have farmed out our manufacturing to that country, where workers' rights, health and safety, anti-slavery rules, can all be ignored without us noticing and we can continue our addiction to endlessly shopping for more and more cheap things. 

In short, what the situation with Putin has highlighted is that we live in an age of hypocrisy - and I don't like it. 

I said at the start that I know nothing, but actually there are two things I know: firstly, I know that I've never felt the resonance of Auden's phrase about "a low, dishonest decade" more strongly, and, secondly, I know that the state of the West and the calibre of its current leaders makes me sick.



No. 1 - that went well!