• 19 Posts
  • 4.31K Comments
Joined 3 years ago
Aquileo | cake
Cake day: July 6th, 2023

Aquileo | help-circle






  • A relevant blog post.

    I think of respect for free speech as a commons. Every time some group invokes free speech to say something controversial, they’re drawing from the commons – which is fine, that’s what the commons is there for. Presumably the commons self-replenishes at some slow rate as people learn philosophy or get into situations where free speech protects them and their allies.

    But if you draw from the commons too quickly, then the commons disappears. When trolls say the most outrageous things possible, then retreat to “oh, but free speech”, they’re burning the commons for no reason, to the detriment of everybody else who needs it.

    But I think that saying or doing controversial things can also strengthen free speech norms in some cases, by establishing awareness that people can say or do those things without being punished. Without knowing more about the particular phenomenon you’re describing (I’ve never come across it myself) I don’t know which is the dominant factor here.


  • I think to me it would depend on what that work was and the person’s attitude towards it. I dated a doctor who complained a lot about how her hospital was making her see too many patients, how the patients were rude to her, and how she had to spend her “free time” at home on paperwork she didn’t have time to do while at work. I was not happy feeling like I was less important to her than a job she didn’t even enjoy. I might have felt otherwise if she absolutely loved her job. (She did see being a doctor as an important duty, and when we talked about this she was hurt that I saw it as a negative because from her point of view it was an example of how she was loyal and dedicated.)