Santa Claus and the Easter Bunny had no chance at our
house. During one of my first casual
conversations with Ellen about who Santa Claus was, she told me he brings
presents to kids on Christmas day. For some reason that really irritated me,
and I quickly responded with something like, “That’s not true. Your parents get
you presents for Christmas because we love you and because we want to celebrate
the gift Heavenly Father gave us when he sent his Son, Jesus Christ, to love us
and teach us and die for us.”
I have had occasional twinges since then; I’ve wondered if
I’ve stunted my children’s ability to believe, imagine, dream, and just be kids, but I’m not really sorry when I really think about it.
The Easter Bunny wasn’t a big deal at my house when I was
growing up. The process of boiling and decorating eggs was much more fun, and
my mom didn’t want us all hopped up on candy right before we went to church.
One of the times we managed to make it to storytime at the library last spring,
the Easter Bunny made a surprise visit, and it was truly terrifying. We’ve had
many conversations before and since that experience about why we celebrate
Easter. It’s so sweet to hear my children talk about being excited to be
able to see their grandmother again.
So one day when Ellen complained that her teeth were
hurting, I took a look and discovered a loose bottom tooth. I have to admit
that I shrieked with excitement. This is a new milestone for me as a mom. One
of the few things I remember from elementary school (both as a student and a
teacher) involves the sheer excitement surrounding the loosening and losing of
teeth. So much time seems to be spent talking about loose teeth, wiggling loose
teeth, waiting for teeth to get loose, guessing who is going to lose the next
tooth.
The next time I looked in Ellen’s mouth, not only did she
have two loose teeth, but the two permanent teeth were already starting to come
in. This worried me, but the two pediatric dentists we go to church with and my
sister (who has gone through lots of loose teeth) all assured me that it’s very
normal. It just looks a little wierd.

Discussions of wiggling, how to get the teeth out, when to
go to the dentist, and when and how the teeth will come out increased. Then I
heard my kids discussing the tooth fairy. Just for the sake of gathering
information, I questioned them.
How does the tooth fairy get in? Maybe down the chimney.
Maybe you can leave the door unlocked.
What does the tooth fairy do? She comes in the night and
takes your tooth and leaves you something.
What does the tooth fairy leave? Sometimes toys, sometimes
money. The [insert family’s name]’s tooth fairy brings quarters. The [insert
family’s name]’s tooth fairy brought [name] twenty dollars!
Doesn’t everyone have the same tooth fairy? I don’t think
so, because my friends all got different things.
What does our tooth fairy bring? I don’t know, but I hope
she brings money.
What if she brings a toy? That’s okay, too, but I really
hope it’s money.
How do you know the tooth fairy is real? What about Santa
Claus and the Easter Bunny? Be quiet, Mom! The tooth fairy is different.
When I related the question and answer session to Jack, he
brought it up again at dinner. “The tooth fairy isn’t real. It’s just like
Santa Claus and the Easter Bunny.” Dad! You’re silly. The tooth fairy IS TOO
REAL!
So I’m pretty sure I haven’t stunted my children’s ability
to believe, imagine, dream, and just be kids. At some point in every book we
read, the Ellen or Jack asks if it’s a real story. They know the stories in the
Bible and the Book of Mormon really happened, that Laura Ingalls Wilder wrote
about her real experiences in the
Little
House books, but that Jack and Annie aren’t real kids and that magic tree
houses don’t really exist. We do look at the places they go on our world map
when we can and talk about what parts of the story could be real.
And since the tooth fairy isn’t related to any
holidays that hold significant meaning for me and my family, I think we’ll roll
with it and see what happens. What a fun
way to celebrate growing up.