Hermetic Library Fellow T Polyphilus reviews Ex Libris [Amazon, Bookshop, Publisher, Local Library] by Matt Madden
I picked up this graphic novel when I noted that it claimed to have been inspired by Italo Calvino’s If on a winter’s night a traveler, a book that I hold in high regard. Ex Libris is not an adaptation of the Calvino work in any sense. It lacks the second-person narrative mode, but includes the metafictional devices that allow for the serial deployment of different genres and styles, and it occasionally strikes the same notes of mise en abyme.
Ex Libris is organized in four chapters, and I read it over three days: Chapter 1, then Chapters 2 & 3, and finally Chapter 4. That pace allowed me to savor the shifts in presentation. The narrating protagonist is isolated and disoriented and alludes repeatedly to a frustrated affectional backstory with “M.” In some respects, these elements reminded me of the Charles Burns Last Look graphic novels from a decade earlier. But they didn’t feel like a satisfying substitute for the second-person mechanism in Calvino’s text.
The pace and interest picked up dramatically in the second and third chapters. While the final chapter did offer a sense of completion (and the recursive epilogue seemed almost inevitable), it failed to blow my mind as I was rooting for it to do.












