Magnifica Humanitas 80: Combatting the Deprivations

80. In this day and age, social justice must also grapple with the environment shaped by digital technologies. The spread of global networks, platforms and artificial intelligence systems is changing the way we obtain information, communicate and access services. Justice demands that we prevent the emergence of new forms of exclusion and deprivation of freedoms:

  • individuals and peoples hindered or denied access to basic technologies,
  • communities exposed to invasive surveillance
  • and social groups penalized by opaque algorithms that perpetuate prejudice and discrimination.

One of the features in a near-future science fiction novel I read took for granted these first two. From the moment an immigrant set foot on the moon, their consumption of air, water, and data was monitored. Those three things required payment. According to the author, this was just a way of doing business. One subplot involved a pro-justice initiative to make water and air free for everyone. The character struggled to get traction on that.

Number three is a reality in today’s world.

In the digital age, a just social order guarantees everyone equal access to opportunities, protects the youngest and weakest members of society, combats hate and misinformation and subjects the use of data and technology to public oversight, so that the guiding principle is not solely profit but the dignity of every person and the common good of all people.

This document is on the Vatican site here and is Copyright © Dicastery for Communication – Libreria Editrice Vaticana

Posted in AI, Magnifica Humanitas, Science, social justice | Tagged | Leave a comment

Penance, Appendix I, Dispensation

More in Appendix I in the Order of Penance. Under Dispensation from Irregularity, we read:

3. If a penitent is affected by an irregularity, a Priest, in accordance with the norm of law, when he dispenses the penitent from the irregularity, either during confession, after absolution has been given, or apart from the Sacrament of Penance, says:

By the power granted to me,
I dispense you from the irregularity
which you have incurred.
In the name of the Father, and of the Son, +
and of the Holy Spirit.

The penitent replies:

Amen.

Which begs the question: what is an irregularity? Glad you asked. Sections 1040 and 1041 in canon law cover it. It looks like this one is for priests and deacons, or those who wish to be ordained. Also looks like this dispensation can be given outside of sacramental Penance.

Maybe I’m missing something other than the linked canons. Thoughts?

Posted in Rite of Penance | Tagged , | Leave a comment

Pope Leo on Sacrosanctum Concilium, Part 5.2, A Decisive Perspective

I was wondering when Pope Leo would continue his Wednesday addresses on liturgy. Today, we begin with the why of one of the hallmarks of conciliar reform: participation of the laity:

Indeed, in the Constitution, the term “prayer” designates the liturgy as a whole. This perspective is decisive, for it guided the liturgical reform, making the active participation of the faithful its central pillar.

Liturgy, then, is not just ritual, and not just a formal reality guided by law and detail. All of liturgy is prayer. Not just the prayer of the leadership or the paid classes.

The liturgy is presented first and foremost as the place of encounter, of God’s initiative in drawing near to humanity in his Son, “the Word made flesh, anointed by the Holy Spirit” (SC, 5), to whom we may respond “through Christ, with Christ and in Christ, in the unity of the Holy Spirit”, that is to say, thanks to “the very prayer which Christ Himself, together with His Body, addresses to the Father” (SC, 84).

Liturgists are trained to know that the prayer is first of all the action of the Son directed to the Father. We join in it. We do not create it, either through our art or speech, or even our rubrics and laws.

Let’s look at one of the undoubted failures of Vatican II:

For this reason, Saint Paul VI ardently desired that the Liturgy of the Hours, the Church’s daily public prayer, inseparable from the Eucharist, might deeply permeate, enliven, guide and express all Christian prayer, and effectively nourish the spiritual life of the People of God (cf. Apostolic Constitution Laudis canticum).

This is a worthy ideal, but the reform of the Office was far too timid and limited. It almost had no chance.

For this desire to be fulfilled, the Liturgy of the Hours needs to be more fully embraced and lived out in the daily lives of the baptized and of the communities. To the many people who wish to learn to pray, especially catechumens, it can offer the path and the school of Christian prayer.

I don’t disagree with this, but the reality is that the Church’s only official version is too cumbersome in its published versions. The subscription services that one can pray on a phone are better, but praying outside of a printed book is really a second-best solution. Without significant adaptation the newest edition of the Hours will, I’m sorry to say, be a dead duck except for a small, committed minority. And maybe that’s for the best.

Cited texts are Copyright © Dicastery for Communication – Libreria Editrice Vaticana

Posted in Liturgy, Sacrosanctum Concilium | Tagged | Leave a comment

BEM Ministry 51: Mutual Recognition

We reach our last topic in Baptism, Eucharist, and Ministry. How do we get to mutual recognition of each other’s ordained ministries? It seems like such a chasm to bridge.

VI. TOWARDS THE MUTUAL RECOGNITION OF THE ORDAINED MINISTRIES
51. In order to advance towards the mutual recognition of ministries, deliberate efforts are required. All churches need to examine the forms of ordained ministry and the degree to which the churches are faithful to its original intentions. Churches must be prepared to renew their understanding and their practice of the ordained ministry.

Baptism, Eucharist, and Ministry, the Faith and Order Paper no. 111 of the World Council of Churches is Copyright © 1982 World Council of Churches, 150 route de Ferney, 1211 Geneva 2, Switzerland. Link available on this page.

Posted in BEM, ecumenism | Leave a comment

Arachnofeasting

Something big might have flown through this trap. but there are a lot of morsels that were caught. It doesn’t look like one of those zombie spider’s webs. This one, likely just damaged.

Posted in Nature | Leave a comment

Magnifica Humanitas 79: Structures of Sin

Catholics put stock in a systemic thing like original sin. It’s not a big leap to consider that some larger assemblages of people produce injustice on a significant scale.

79. The idea of “social justice” helps us recognize that injustices do not arise solely from the wrong choices of individuals, but also from structures, mechanisms and economic and cultural systems that produce inequality almost automatically. Saint John Paul II spoke in this vein of structures of sin [Cf. Sollicitudo Rei Socialis 36-37] that oppose God’s will and require a commitment to personal and social conversion.

Personal conversion does require an acknowledgement of social sin, and of our occasional benefit from it. Advocacy for change is also part of the Christian endeavor in this area. This involves not just the spreading around of money and resources and evening out everyone’s pile. A human and social restoration is needed:

In this perspective, justice is not merely about the fairer distribution of resources or the correction of current injustices, but also assumes a restorative dimension. It aims to mend broken bonds and reintegrate those who have been excluded, taking into account the wounds caused by injustices, such as wars, colonialism, racial or gender discrimination, violence against entire peoples and exploitation. This may include restoring dignity and a voice to those who have been ignored, fostering processes of healing for collective memory, opposing discriminatory laws and practices, and providing concrete support to those who still bear the consequences of wrongs suffered in the past.

Hands wring over reparations, for example. By Pope Leo’s assessment writing a check to every slavery descendant would be insufficient, if not wrong-headed. School tuition or job training, perhaps, would not be. Creativity and thought would be needed for a lasting effort here.

This document is on the Vatican site here and is Copyright © Dicastery for Communication – Libreria Editrice Vaticana

Posted in AI, Magnifica Humanitas, Science, social justice | Tagged | Leave a comment

Shade To Orange, Again

This was captured about eighty minutes before sunset tonight. The sun got more orange on the drive to retrieve the young miss from work. Ash from western fires is coming.

Unless or until scientists are permitted to put our full resources into the challenges of climate change, I think this will be a seasonal reality for the planet. We are at a point where we must concede defeat, and do our best to mitigate disruption and damage.

Posted in Nature | Leave a comment

Pope Leo on Sacrosanctum Concilium, Part 5.1 Prayer Is Fundamental to Our Humanity

I was wondering when Pope Leo would be resuming his weekly catechesis on Sacrosanctum Concilium. We left off mid-constitution in June. Fresh off his July vacation, he dives back in, leading us in the theme of liturgical prayer, leaning into the Liturgy of Hours. But first, let’s begin with the power of the Spirit:

As the Apostle Paul suggests, it is the Holy Spirit who teaches us to pray. From the day of Pentecost, the Spirit dwells in the Church, inspiring every one of her activities and, in particular, prayer. The life of the first community, born in Jerusalem after the Pasch of Jesus, is life in the Spirit given by the risen Lord. “From that time onwards the Church has never failed to come together to celebrate the paschal mystery: reading those things ‘which were in all the scriptures concerning him’ (Luke 24:27), celebrating the Eucharist in which ‘the victory and triumph of his death are again made present’, and at the same time giving thanks ‘to God for his unspeakable gift’ (2 Corinthians 9:15) in Christ Jesus, ‘in praise of his glory’ (Ephesians 1:12), through the power of the Holy Spirit” (SC, 6).

This quote from early in the constitution seems less cited than other notions–source and summit, participation, noble simplicity, adaptation, and inculturation. Paschal Mystery is important for us, as much as anything. I remember a task of reading biblical books when I was a new Catholic. I think I was only dimly aware of the Paschal Mystery as such. I certainly knew the Passion, Death, Resurrection, and Ascension. I could find them in the Bible and in the liturgy. Did I make the connection to Mass? My experience as a youth was that these were disconnected. It wasn’t until my post-college days that things began to tie together, including the Divine Office.

In our time, in contexts dominated by an efficiency-driven and consumerist mindset, prayer may seem pointless and trivial.

I’ve even encountered the occasional Christian who leans in this direction. Action often trumps contemplation in the minds and practices of some people.

In a world where science and technology claim to provide all the answers, praying may appear to be a form of escapism. Furthermore, even in many Christian families, the tradition of prayer is no longer passed on, whilst many people risk confusing it with just another technique, of a psychological nature aimed at personal well-being.

Thank you, Holy Father. I grow weary of citations and studies that find prayer lowers blood pressure, extends life, improves one’s social relationships, cures cancer, etc,, Yes, prayer has praiseworthy side effects, perhaps. But the believer might suggest prayer is part of a human identity than longs for union with God. Whether we speak, sing, dance, read, recite a mantra, or be still we aspire to reconnect with God in the same way we seek out companionship, or even food, drink, and air.

Prayer, however, as a fundamental dimension of our humanity, is worth rediscovering in its true form.

God comes first, we are told. A priest friend once adopted a personal slogan as he began his day: no Bible, no breakfast. Not everyone wakes at dawn, or manages an early morning, but I admired my friend’s lived-out notion of God coming first.

The Constitution Sacrosanctum Concilium took this need seriously. This greatly pleased Pope Saint Paul VI, who, on promulgating this first document approved by the Second Vatican Council, stated: “God comes first; prayer is our primary duty; the liturgy is the primary source of the divine life communicated to us, the primary school of our spiritual life” (Address, Saint Peter’s Basilica, 4 December 1963).

I don’t always feel at ease with “school,” but I can appreciate that prayer forms us for knowledge as well as action in the world.

What do you make of this catechesis from Pope Leo? How can the modern believer–and I include people outside of Christianity who believe in God–activate this school of spiritual life?

Cited texts are Copyright © Dicastery for Communication – Libreria Editrice Vaticana

Posted in Liturgy, Sacrosanctum Concilium | Tagged | Leave a comment

BEM Ministry 50: Prejudices

50. Churches which refuse to consider candidates for the ordained ministry on the ground of handicap or because they belong, for example, to one particular race or sociological group should re-evaluate their practices. This re-evaluation is particularly important today in view of the multitude of experiments in new forms of ministry with which the churches are approaching the modern world.

This should go without saying, but outside of the issues surrounding sexism and misogyny, perhaps we’ve had some progress in this area. Mutual recognition for other stated reasons unrelated to the actual prejudice is likely a problem here and there still.

Baptism, Eucharist, and Ministry, the Faith and Order Paper no. 111 of the World Council of Churches is Copyright © 1982 World Council of Churches, 150 route de Ferney, 1211 Geneva 2, Switzerland. Link available on this page.

Posted in BEM, ecumenism | 1 Comment

Magnifica Humanitas 78: Preferential Option for the Poor

Two popes have leaned into the preferential option. One we examined two years ago here, something the US Bishops endorsed and promoted before the culturewarriors took over the conference.

78. The recent Magisterium has insisted that social justice begins with the least among us. Saint John Paul II spoke of a preferential option for the poor [Cf. Sollicitudo Rei Socialis 42] that must guide both personal and societal choices, while Pope Francis denounced a “‘throw away’ culture” [Evangelii Gaudium 53] that generates ever new forms of exclusion.

We checked that out too, here. Pope Francis thought it was getting worse in 2013-14, and I can’t say I’ve seen much movement away from our world’s deeply unhealthy transactionalism. As long as people in power view the needy as a resource to be exploited for cheap labor, corporate theft, and manipulation, we will not be able to reverse the trend.

From this perspective, social justice requires us to look at individuals and communities, starting with the most vulnerable: the poor, migrants, refugees, internally displaced persons, victims of violence and people living in urban or existential peripheries.

Those peripheries are everywhere: let’s not delude ourselves about it.

This document is on the Vatican site here and is Copyright © Dicastery for Communication – Libreria Editrice Vaticana

Posted in AI, Magnifica Humanitas, Science, social justice | Tagged | Leave a comment

BEM Ministry 49: Mutual Recognition

A small thing, but easier said than accepted:

49. The discipline with regard to the conditions for ordination in one church need not be seen as universally applicable and used as grounds for not recognizing ministry in others.

Many Christians struggle with others not like themselves. Sometimes the recognition is grounded in thoughtful theological principles. Sometimes it is just suspicion of the other. On one level it is easy to recognize that an ordained person in another tradition has a fruitful ministry with those she or he serves. And sometimes the gulf is too wide, not just the theological.

Baptism, Eucharist, and Ministry, the Faith and Order Paper no. 111 of the World Council of Churches is Copyright © 1982 World Council of Churches, 150 route de Ferney, 1211 Geneva 2, Switzerland. Link available on this page.

Posted in BEM, ecumenism | Leave a comment

Magnifica Humanitas 77: The Principle of Social Justice

Subsidiarity and solidarity are wekk within the bounds of Catholic teaching. If we were to look in the teachings of the Lord in the Gospels, social justice is even more obvious to those who read the Scriptures carefully. It isn’t just about Jesus–he didn’t invent social justice. One can find it all over the prophets and psalms.

The principle of social justice

77. For the Christian community, social justice is a concrete way of following Jesus and remaining faithful to the Gospel. In the New Testament, Jesus proclaims the “good news to the poor” (Luke 4:18) and identifies himself with the lowly, the sick, the imprisoned and strangers (cf. Matthew 25:31-46).

That good news is in the Isaiah tradition, from 61:1-3. Jesus’ alignment with the needy is a bit more than just identification. It is such an explicit expression of his Presence we would do very well to honor it as he indicates.

He thus teaches us that justice is born from, and fulfilled in, fraternity, because the way we approach and relate to the least among us becomes, in concrete terms, the measure of our relationship with God and with our brothers and sisters.

To be clear, justice goes beyond charity, and it involves the greater currents in society–law, policy, economics certainly.

Justice, however, concerns not only the behavior of individuals, but also the way in which the structures of society are conceived and organized. In this regard, the Second Vatican Council reminds us that every institution is called to serve the human person and his or her dignity. [Cf. Gaudium et Spes 25] Social justice is, therefore, characterized by the capacity of a social, economic and political order to allow everyone — particularly the weakest — to live a truly dignified life, without leaving anyone behind.

Not leaving anyone behind: a tradition of honor we would do well to embrace a bit more fully than we have in the past.

This document is on the Vatican site here and is Copyright © Dicastery for Communication – Libreria Editrice Vaticana

Posted in AI, Magnifica Humanitas, Science, social justice | Tagged | Leave a comment

BEM Ministry 48: Time Away

48. Initial commitment to ordained ministry ought normally to be made without reserve or time limit. Yet leave of absence from service is not incompatible with ordination. Resumption of ordained ministry re-quires the assent of the Church, but no re-ordination.

This would certainly be the Roman understanding, that ordination is non-repeatable. Human beings, of course, sometimes deal with the fading of fervor for service. Is this a matter of trust in God? Of trust in an initial discernment, perhaps in a time of deep consolation and affirmation? This is a matter for pastoral counseling and the guidance of a bishop or mentor or even the faith community.

In recognition of the God-given charism of ministry, ordination to any one of the particular ordained ministries is never repeated.

Baptism, Eucharist, and Ministry, the Faith and Order Paper no. 111 of the World Council of Churches is Copyright © 1982 World Council of Churches, 150 route de Ferney, 1211 Geneva 2, Switzerland. Link available on this page.

Posted in BEM, ecumenism | Leave a comment

Magnifica Humanitas 76: Global Solidarity

Pope Benedict enters our discussion today. Anybody surprised? I don’t think we should be.

76. In a world marked by increasingly close connections between people, communities and nations, solidarity also takes on a global dimension. Benedict XVI strongly emphasized the link between development, justice and responsibility toward future generations, stating that authentic development requires solidarity and inter-generational justice, [Cf. Caritas in Veritate 48] as well as an awareness of the bonds that unite us to the natural environment.

Solidarity includes our communities joined to the environment and its concerns. This strikes me as sensible. The planet and all levels of its environment–global, regional, local–are concerns of human beings. It would seem our concerns go beyond just the particular air we breathe, the water we drink, the plant and animal material we eat, and the vistas outside our own living spaces. We know what happens in our backyard can damage or even restore what happens in someone else’s.

Let’s not forget the topic of concern, the digital sphere:

Today, this responsibility also extends to digital and information infrastructure. Like the natural environment, the “digital ecosystem” can be preserved or exploited, shared or monopolized. Solidarity demands that decisions regarding data, algorithms, platforms and artificial intelligence take into account not only the immediate benefit for a few, but also the impact on all peoples and on future generations.

This document is on the Vatican site here and is Copyright © Dicastery for Communication – Libreria Editrice Vaticana

Posted in AI, Magnifica Humanitas, Science, social justice | Tagged | Leave a comment

Penance, Appendix I: Absolution From Censures

Almost two decades ago, we took a fairly close look at the Rite of Penance, now known as the Order of. Reviving the series, and following on the heels of its last effort, a near-complete examination of Scriptures used in the sacrament, I think it might be interesting to review some of the ritual elements and suggestions in its three appendices. Today, the first of two brief looks at Appendix I. Let’s begin with the Absolution from Censures. As I see it, this isn’t strictly a liturgical event, though censures may be absolved within the rite or even some sort of prayer experience. Officially, the Church is concerned with the restoration of a believer’s status after a serious offense. This act must be published somewhere, so I suppose the Order of Penance is the optimal choice.

Let’s read:

1. When a Priest, in accordance with the norm of law, absolves a properly disposed penitent within the sacramental forum from a censure latae sententiae, the formula of absolution is not to be changed. It is enough that the confessor intend to absolve the properly disposed penitent also from censures. Before absolving from sins, however, the confessor may absolve the censure, using the formula that is given below for use outside the Sacrament of Penance.

2. When a Priest, in accordance with the norm of law, absolves a penitent from a censure outside the Sacrament of Penance, he uses the following formula:

By the power granted to me,
I absolve you from the bond of excommunication
(or: suspension or: interdict).
In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit.

The penitent replies:

Amen

If you are interested in the canonical details of this, an appropriate section in canon law is here. I suppose this is timely news, in case any SSPX folks are leaning back into the fold.

Posted in Rite of Penance | Tagged , | 1 Comment