
I like Colin Conway as a writer. One of the things I like about his work is that he generally keeps the politics low-key.
That is not true, however, of Cutlerâs Friend, the third volume in his John Cutler series. The author published those first three books early in the 2000s, and the era may be part of the problem. This book is (in my opinion) more suited to the zeitgeist of that decade than to the present.
At the beginning of Cutlerâs Friend, John has stabilized his life somewhat. He is now a licensed private investigator in Spokane, and he has a regular girlfriend.
He gets a visit from Mike, his former partner on the Seattle police force. Mike has, John discovers, become a pretty nasty racist, largely because his wife Tina left him for a black professional athlete. John wouldnât care to do a favor for Mike at this point, but itâs Tina who needs help. Her new husband has been murdered, and sheâs been arrested for it. Mike wants John to prove sheâs innocent.
As John begins the investigation, the job raises tension with his girlfriend Erika, who is black. She starts discussing racial issues with John, and distancing herself from him. He finally realizes that he has to choose between helping an innocent woman and keeping his girlfriend.
This book pushed all my buttons â negatively. It started with a scene where John is dealing with a guy in a wig and a dress, in which he keeps condemning himself for âprejudiceâ when he forgets to use âherâ preferred pronouns. Then we go on to the scenes with Erika, where the point seems to be that, as a miserable white man, thereâs nothing John is allowed to do but kneel in repentance and apologize forever.
This bothered me a lot. Because if thatâs the way the races have to relate to one another, it will always be impossible for us love each other, or even to be friends. Itâs a formula for eternal racial segregation. I have to believe thereâs some better way.
If I werenât already fond of the series, Iâd have dropped it with Cutlerâs Friend. But Iâm reading on. People learn and grow, and I see no signs of this kind of self-conscious political correctness in Colin Conwayâs later work.












